October 3, 2007
Viewer: "Like Watching Home Shopping Network"
 |
CBS
Some called Steve Kroft's piece on Clarence Thomas, left, an "advertorial" or a "puff piece." |
"60 MINUTES goal in this rare interview was to provide as complete a picture of Justice Thomas as we could. We believe we succeeded," "60 Minutes" spokesman Kevin Tedesco told Journal-isms, referring to Sunday night's broadcast.
"Everyone is entitled to his or her opinion but I'd point out that we did have Anita Hill on GMA yesterday and she was quite tough on Thomas," Jeffrey W. Schneider, spokesman for ABC News, told Journal-isms. His references were to Hill, who accused Thomas of sexual harassment during his 1991 confirmation hearings, and to ABC's "Good Morning America."
"In addition, Jan's interview was both fair and probing," Schneider said, referring to a series of reports by Jan Crawford Greenburg that aired on "Nightline" and other ABC programs.
As noted Monday, the reviews were different on the e-mail list of the National Association of Black Journalists, and in a discussion of the "60 Minutes" piece on PBS' "The Tavis Smiley Show."
"I've now watched the 60 Minutes interview and the Nightline interview. It was like watching the Home Shopping Network," wrote one. "You mean to tell me that there was not a single critical commentator on Clarence Thomas' record? These things could have been on Larry King and no one would have blinked. I'm rarely disgusted, but this was pure journalistic drivel."
Another said, "I also find it very interesting that the only real televised critic was Al Sharpton in the 60 minutes piece. Given his baggage — and the way whites feel about him, [it] seemed like an attempt to discount the merits of the criticism."
"It was a soft-ball interview designed to sell books for Thomas. Frankly, I'm surprised at CBS," a third said.
"Do you think after the whole Dan Rather fiasco that they're forgoing the tough Mike Wallace approach for something more Larry King-ish?" a fourth said, referring to a discredited story about President Bush's military service.
The first poster replied, "I also noticed that there was no mention by either show to say whether they'd attempted to interview Anita Hill for comment. Nor did they refer to her New York Times editorial as a counterpoint to Thomas' viewpoint. During the Nightline interview, they did something that just astounded me. Thomas talked about how Democratic Senators smiled in his face and lied to him and ABC ran archival footage of Joe Biden smiling in slow motion while The Temps' 'Smiling Faces' played in the background. It was propaganda and not news."
On the Smiley show, Marc Morial, president of the National Urban League, Princeton professor Cornel West and Farah Griffin, director of Columbia University's Institute for Research in African American Studies, were equally critical of the "60 Minutes" piece. "Nightline" had not yet aired.
"It was an advertorial for Clarence Thomas and perhaps for the book," Morial said.
"I think that CBS and '60 Minutes,' they really ought to be ashamed of themselves," West said. "Because you get another example of debased journalism where there's no Socratic energy, no tough questions raised. I have nothing against staying in contact with the humanity of Brother Clarence Thomas, and we did see humanity, his story, his relation to grandfather, and so forth.
"I don't want to demonize the brother, but he needs to be criticized, and they presented this story as if those of us who are critics, Black, White, Red, or whatever, have no good reasons to be critical of him siding with the strong against the weak and the powerful against the relatively powerless."
A right-wing blogger had this comeback: "Those people who thought Steve Kroft's interview with Clarence Thomas on Sunday's 60 Minutes was not tough enough should remember that Anita Hill received a very gentle 60 Minutes treatment on February 2, 1992," wrote Tim Graham on the NewsBusters site. "Ed Bradley drew out the disclosure that she was a Democrat, but went on with a set of gooey questions about whether she has Eleanor Roosevelt quotes on her office wall."
The two networks are not the only media outlets with pieces on Thomas that might be considered uncritical.
"Rush Limbaugh, the conservative talk radio host, also interviewed Justice Thomas. He dedicated 90 minutes to the conversation on Monday, setting a record: 'No guest has ever gone longer than one hour on this program,' Mr. Limbaugh noted," Brian Stelter reported in his TV Decoder blog for the New York Times Web site.
Jet magazine boasts — inaccurately — in its upcoming Oct. 15 issue that Thomas has "agreed to sit down with JET Magazine for his first and only magazine or newspaper interview since being named to the Supreme Court in 1991."
Headlined "Clarence Thomas Says He's An Independent, Misunderstood And Proud Black Man," the piece by Kevin Chappell begins:
"Spend a little time at the U.S. Supreme Court with Justice Clarence Thomas and you are quickly taken aback by two things: His booming infectious laugh that permeates his office and rumbles through the hollowed corridors of the historic Washington, D.C., building; and the surprisingly normal fare that the Yale-educated lawyer finds humorous."
Thomas was interviewed by a group of black reporters in 1995, by Chris Mondics of the Philadelphia Inquirer in 2003 and by Diane Brady of Business Week magazine this year.
MESSAGE BOARDS: Feel free to post a comment on this subject and view those from others.
. . . Anita Hill Has Her Say in Print, on TV
Anita Hill, who accused Clarence Thomas of sexual harassment during his 1991 confirmation hearings for Supreme Court justice, is not remaining silent as Thomas promotes his version of their clash."Justice Thomas has every right to present himself as he wishes in his new memoir, 'My Grandfather's Son,'" Hill wrote in a New York Times op-ed piece Tuesday, "The Smear This Time."
"He may even be entitled to feel abused by the confirmation process that led to his appointment to the Supreme Court.
"But I will not stand by silently and allow him, in his anger, to reinvent me.
"In the portion of his book that addresses my role in the Senate hearings into his nomination, Justice Thomas offers a litany of unsubstantiated representations and outright smears that Republican senators made about me when I testified before the Judiciary Committee — that I was a 'combative left-winger' who was 'touchy' and prone to overreacting to 'slights.' A number of independent authors have shown those attacks to be baseless."
Hill also made television appearances on NBC and CNN, among other outlets.
The Boston Globe filled in readers on Hill's whereabouts. "A few weeks ago, she began a sabbatical from her teaching job at Brandeis University, beginning a one-year stint as a visiting scholar at Wellesley College that will enable her for the first time to go through all of the 20,000 or so letters she received after testifying against Thomas," the Globe's Michael Kranish reported Wednesday.
On National Public Radio's "Tell Me More," Kevin Merida of the Washington Post, co-author of the recent "Supreme Discomfort" book on Thomas, said there were "competing facts" involving Hill and Thomas, and "all kinds of complications that independent journalists, other books have dealt with. And Justice Thomas does not really deal with the complete set of facts in these cases."
Meanwhile, the Heritage Foundation held a dinner Monday night honoring Thomas and invited "a group of bloggers and other opinion journalists," as James Joyner, one of the bloggers, reported on Tuesday.
LaShawn Barber, a black conservative, wrote on her blog after the event, "Justice Thomas told us a couple of anecdotes about how two black men at different events 'confronted' him, asked him questions, listened civilly to the answers, and concluded: 'Why are they lying about you? What can we do about it?'"
Thomas friend Armstrong Williams, the conservative commentator and entrepreneur, was scheduled to have a book party Wednesday night for Thomas at his Capitol Hill home, putting two entire city blocks off-limits to residents, the Washington Post's "Reliable Source" column reported on Monday. The Hill, the Capitol Hill newspaper, reported Thursday that the guest list included actor Will Smith, White House Chief of Staff Josh Bolten, ABC newswoman Barbara Walters, CBS Sports' James Brown, ESPN's Stephen A. Smith, ex-NBA star Charles Barkley and Bob Jones of Bob Jones University.
-
Tim Graham, Newsbusters.org blog:
Clarence Thomas to Bloggers: Wish You'd Been Around in 1991!
-
Earl Ofari Hutchinson, syndicated:
More Than His Grandfather's Son: Understanding Clarence Thomas
-
Ed Morrisey, Captains Quarters blog:
An Evening With Justice Thomas
-
The Nation:
Clarence Thomas and Rupert Murdoch
- Eugene Robinson, Washington Post:
Witness for the Persecution
Grambling Removes Material from Paper's Web Site
 |
Chris Day/The News Star
De'Eric Henry, editor-in-chief of Grambling State University's newspaper the Gramblinite, had agreed to remove only some photos. |
"The Gramblinite sent a reporter and photographer Friday to cover an event designed to teach young students about racism in the context of the Jena Six case. One of the images taken showed a girl — a student at Grambling's Alma J. Brown Elementary lab school — held up in the air with a noose placed around her neck.
"'We knew it was a controversial photo,' said De'Eric Henry, editor in chief of The Gramblinite. 'That's why we did not run it in the paper. We ran it as a photo gallery online.'
"The Monroe, La. News Star reported Sunday that the child featured in the photo apparently was taking part in a lesson about events surrounding the six black students charged in the 2006 beating of a white student in Jena, La.'
"Henry said he received a call from his news editor while driving to Dallas to cover a sports event. The news editor told him that members of the administration had requested the photos be removed.
"Henry held a phone conference with his fellow editors, deciding to remove only the photos involving the noose.
"But Henry returned from his trip Monday morning to find all the photos, and the story itself, removed from the Web site. Henry said someone from the university president's office had called Wanda Peters, The Gramblinite's adviser, and asked that all the material be taken down."
Provost Robert M. Dixon sent out a memorandum Jan. 17 suspending the newspaper for the rest of January "or until administrators are content with greater 'quality assurance' of the paper," as the News-Star in Monroe, La., put it. It followed complaints about a plagiarized story.
Editors defied the order and published on Jan. 18. After a torrent of criticism from media organizations, the university dropped its requirement that the student newspaper submit all its stories to a faculty adviser for editing.
University spokesman Ralph Wilson told Journal-isms he could not address how the university's action squared with the January agreement, but said the university had received complaints from parents and others.
-
Lawrence Aaron, the Record, Hackensack, N.J.:
Why the symbolism of the Jena 6 hits home
-
Sylvester Brown Jr., St. Louis Post-Dispatch:
Perceptions, prosecutors and reason —
and race
-
Paul V. Carty, Gannett Co.:
Covering the big story (Jena Six): Push to own it and have faith in your talent
-
Jarvis DeBerry, New Orleans Times-Picayune:
Jena DA changes tune, or gets it changed
-
Jerry Large, Seattle Times:
Look past symbols of Jena
-
Al Tompkins, Poynter Institute:
A Small Paper's Lessons from the 'Jena Six' Story
-
Dawn Turner Trice, Chicago Tribune:
Jena 6 case isn't perfect, but it's clear
-
Leonard Pitts Jr., Miami Herald:
Multiply sense of betrayal by 388 years
-
Tonyaa Weathersbee, BlackAmericaWeb.com:
Please Don't Screw Up Again, Mychal Bell – You Owe Too
Many People, Yourself Included
MESSAGE BOARDS: Feel free to post a comment on this subject and view those from others.
Is Barack Obama Actually Charlie Brown?
 |
Drew Friedman/The New York Observer
"It's Your Campaign, Barack Obama: Has Hillary Clinton grabbed the football?" the New York Observer asks in this week's edition. |
"It's Your Campaign, Barack Obama: Has Hillary Clinton grabbed the football? Is the Illinois senator wishy-washy?" the caption reads. It accompanies a story by Jason Horowitz, "Clinton Campaign Gets In Gloat Mode With $27 Million; Hillary Donor Chortles: Massive Haul More Than Obama, Edwards Combined."
The Charlie Brown image also made the cover.
Meanwhile, Obama met with black journalists in South Carolina, Mary C. Curtis reported in her Charlotte (N.C.) Observer column.
"My report: He cannot walk on water but he can speak with passion about issues he believes are important — and crack an occasional joke."
-
David Roybal, Albuquerque (N.M.) Journal:
All Eyes on Richardson
MESSAGE BOARDS: Feel free to post a comment on this subject and view those from others.
Professor Defends Calling Williams "Happy Negro"
Boyce D. Watkins, an African American Syracuse University finance professor, is standing by his calling reporter and commentator Juan Williams a "Happy Negro," a phrase Watkins used on television after Williams defended Fox host Bill O'Reilly.O'Reilly had remarked in an interview with Williams that he had eaten in Sylvia's, a black-owned soul-food restaurant in Harlem, and found it no different from eating in a white one.
Williams wrote an essay Friday in Time magazine saying the "Happy Negro" remark was "a pathetic cowardly, personal attack against me intended to damage my credibility and invalidate any support I offer to O'Reilly against the charges that he is a racist."
Watkins replied in his own piece, "On CNN, I essentially explained that anyone who thought Bill O'Reilly was suddenly a reformed racist who'd seen the light has been getting high with Bobby and Whitney too long. I've been on this man's show before, and he has consistently demeaned, degraded and devalued everything about black culture he could get his hands on. I also mentioned that I was unimpressed with Juan Williams' agreement and defense of O'Reilly. Seeing Williams sitting there congratulating O'Reilly for his bigotry reminded me of the Negro in the white suit defending 'massa' at all costs. His attitudes were consistent with his latest and most terrible book, which does nothing but blast black culture and black people, as if we are the sole causes of socioeconomic inequality.
"Therefore, I could only use terms I felt appropriate. I defined Williams as 'The Happy Negro'. On CNN, I compared O'Reilly's use of Williams to Hugh Hefner hiring a stripper to tell him that he's not a sexist. The 'Happy Negro' was no longer happy when he heard what I had to say."
In an interview Wednesday with the Daily Orange, the student newspaper at Syracuse University, Watkins said of his essay, "I didn't want to publish it in Time magazine, I wanted to publish it directly with the black community, so I sent it to Essence magazine, also Black America Web and blacknews.com, which are highly read Web sites in the black community. . . . It's just really one of those things that represents the division going on in the black community."
-
The Hill:
Juan Williams unhappy as 'happy Negro' (second item)
-
Ari Melber, the Nation:
The FOX-NPR Tension
-
Keith Olbermann video, MSNBC:
Countdown: Bill O'Reilly Defense Initiative
MESSAGE BOARDS: Feel free to post a comment on this subject and view those from others.
Explanation of Columnist's Plight Challenged
"The folks at 1100 Broadway are engaging in some sophisticated camouflage after we reported last week the paper's inhumane treatment of cancer survivor and erstwhile Tennessean columnist Tim Chavez," Liz Garrigan, editor of the Nashville Scene, wrote Tuesday in her blog. "In addition to characterizing our reporting as 'the usual twisted, vitriolic drivel from a local alternative newspaper,' publisher Ellen Leifeld claimed that Chavez hadn't been able to come back because his doctor hadn't released him.
 |
| Tim Chavez |
"'After our conversation, I was thinking about your interest/intention in coming back to a job here and wanted to make sure you had an update on our staffing situation,' the HR official wrote. 'I'm sure you've heard from other staffers that we recently downsized in the newsroom as well as other departments through a voluntary severance plan, which included reduction of editorial staff where you most recently worked. The job you formerly held does not exist anymore. There are other jobs that are open, and perhaps more will come open. They are/will be jobs targeted specifically to fit with the goals of the information center going forward. You are welcome to apply for any of the open jobs and will be considered on how your qualifications meet the job requirements.'
"Course, if we'd treated a staffer this way, we would probably obfuscate and engage in transference too."
Leifeld told Journal-isms, "My only comment is that this is a personnel matter that we are attempting to work out."
MESSAGE BOARDS: Feel free to post a comment on this subject and view those from others.
 |
Oliphant (c) 2007 Universal Press Syndicate. Used by permission. All rights reserved.
Pat Oliphant's syndicated cartoon ran in the mainstream press in September. |
 |
Walt Carr
. . . and Walt Carr's cartoon ran in the black press last week. |
Surprise! Another Racial Divide Over O.J.
If the cartoons from Pat Oliphant (mainstream press) and Walt Carr (black press) aren't evidence enough, the Associated Press reported last week that, "Far more whites than blacks say O.J. Simpson will be tried fairly in his armed robbery case and think he is guilty, according to a poll released Thursday that underscores the nation's racial divide over its justice system and the tarnished celebrity."While 70 percent of whites said they believe this month's charges against Simpson are true, only 41 percent of blacks said so, according to an Associated Press-Ipsos poll. And while 73 percent of whites said they believe he will have a fair trial, only 36 percent of blacks agreed.
". . . Simpson was released from jail Wednesday after posting $125,000 bail in connection with the armed robbery of sports memorabilia collectors at a Las Vegas hotel."
-
Ana Menendez, Miami Herald:
O.J. Simpson is yearning to be locked up
-
Anthony Asadullah Samad, BlackCommentator.com:
O.J. "Dumb Sh*t": Do We Really Need This Right Now?
- Mary Sanchez, Kansas City Star: Focus on the lessons of O.J., not the man
Short Takes
 |
| Caesar Andrews |
-
"Caesar Andrews, executive editor of the Detroit Free Press, was
elected treasurer-designate of the American Society of Newspaper
Editors during the group's fall board meeting in Dallas," ASNE announced on Tuesday. "Andrews will
become treasurer of the group in April 2008 at the annual convention
and will rise through the officer ranks each year until reaching the
ASNE presidency in April 2011. This will be the second presidency of a
major journalism organization that Andrews will assume, having served
as 2002 president of the Associated Press Managing Editors."
-
"Citadel Broadcasting is close to finalizing a contract with Don Imus that would bring the controversial radio host back to the airwaves, a
person familiar with the discussions said Tuesday," Neil Best
reported
Wednesday in Newsday. "It was not immediately clear from where Imus
would be heard, but
Citadel owns WABC in New York, making its morning slot a logical
destination. It also owns WPLJ-FM."
-
"After two decades of cutbacks in
international bureaus, ABC News is bucking the trend by creating
one-person operations that will dramatically boost its coverage in
Africa, India and elsewhere," Paul J. Gough reported
Wednesday in the Hollywood Reporter. "The mini-bureaus are being
opened in Seoul; Rio de Janeiro;
Dubai; New
Delhi and Mumbai, India; Jakarta, Indonesia; and Nairobi, Kenya."
-
"The Milwaukee Journal Sentinel announced Tuesday it is
cutting its workforce," Katie DeLong reported
Tuesday in that newspaper. "The paper is offering to buy out up to 50
full-time employees with 10 years
of service or more. If they are not taken, the paper will make
involuntary cuts."
-
The New York Times ran this
correction
in a story reporting that a jury ruled that Isiah Thomas, the coach of
the New York
Knicks, sexually harassed a former team executive: "An earlier version
of this article misstated
the location of a 2005 sexual encounter between Stephon Marbury of the
Knicks and a team
intern. Mr. Marbury testified that it took place in his truck, not in
the trunk of his car."
-
In India, "In a bizarre incident, a cameraman working with a local news
channel hungry for an 'exclusive' exhorted an entire family to commit
suicide in order to attract the district administration's attention to
their plight," the Times of India
reported
on Monday. "For a change the police arrived before the gory scene
could be enacted and arrested the cameraman, Vipin, who had managed to
convince Tilak Raj, a local businessman fallen on hard times, to
consume poison."
-
"New York Times metro reporter Jennifer 8. Lee, who has been working
the night shift for the city section since January 2006, will move
full-time to City Room, the Times' local news blog," Leon Neyfakh reported
Monday in the New York Observer. "Ms. Lee, who has written some of the
Times' most widely-read
conceptual pieces in the past few years, recently completed her book
on the history of Chinese food in the United States, which is due out
in March. She will start filing to City Room, which is led by reporter
Sewell Chan and edited by metro deputy Patrick LaForge, today."
-
Lolis Eric Elie, metro columnist for the New Orleans Times-Picayune,
has co-written "Faubourg Tremé: The Untold Story of Black New
Orleans," a documentary for which there will be sneak previews at New
Orleans' Canal Place Cinema on Oct. 14. "This project has been the
great drain on my time for about 5 years now," Elie told Journal-isms.
"Much of it revolves around the story of Paul Trevigne, the editor of
two Civil War Era black newspapers. He was still at it 40 years later
when they started the agitation that became Plessy v. Ferguson. We're
hoping it'll be on PBS next year."
-
"Now the State Department is in the blogosphere, and says it
'offers the public an alternative source to mainstream media for U.S.
foreign policy information,'" Al Kamen reported
Wednesday in the Washington Post. "The blog, launched last week and called
'Dipnote,' is 'taking you behind the scenes.'"
-
"I'm headed back to Stanford. I'm headed back to a wonderful life in
California, where eventually I can end up back in a classroom,"
Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice told Dominic Carter on Tuesday in
an
interview
with the New York cable channel NY1. She was asked what she would do
if queried about a spot on
the Republican ticket.
-
Howard University's WHUR-FM has been
named
"Urban Station of the Year" by the National Association of
Broadcasters. "WHUR is the only
stand-alone station in the market, yet has consistently enjoyed
ratings success over its media
conglomerate competitors, ranked the #1 radio station in the 2007
Arbitron Winter [ratings]
Book," the NAB said. "A dedicated part of the community, WHUR yearly
provides more than
$2,000,000 in public service, news and information, civic, and church
related announcements."
-
"Who would have 'thunk' that in a state Indian activists called
'The Mississippi of the North' in the 1970s, would be the only state
in the Union that does not celebrate Columbus Day, but instead
celebrates 'Native American Day,'" columnist Tim Giago, speaking of
South Dakota,'
wrote in the
Native Times. "The credit must go to the power of the Indian press."
-
A report from the Committee to Protect Journalists "examines the
adversity facing journalists in
the volatile Horn of Africa through the stories of two newsmen who
tried to flee the
region. In a two-part special
report, CPJ recounts editor Befekadu
Moreda's remarkable journey out of Ethiopia and sportscaster Paulos
Kidane's fateful effort to flee Eritrean government oppression," the
committee said on Wednesday.
-
"Reporters Without Borders urged President Pervez Musharraf of
Pakistan "to react
firmly after at least 30 journalists were wounded by police trying to
stop them covering a crackdown on demonstrations in Islamabad and
Peshawar by lawyers opposing the president's candidacy at upcoming
elections," the organization
said
on Monday.
-
The Hillary Clinton campaign announced last week that Florida attorney Willie
E. Gary, who pioneered the short-lived Black Family Channel, has been
named as national campaign co-chair, BlackAmericaWeb.com and the
Associated Press
reported
on Wednesday.
 |
| Jennifer 8. Lee |
MESSAGE BOARDS: Feel free to post a comment on this subject and view those from others.
Send tips and comments to Richard Prince.
To be notified of new columns, contact journal-isms-subscribe@yahoogroups.com and tell us who you are
View previous columns.
Five Minutes With Richard Prince (Newspaper Association of America)
to top of page